ETNs, Exchange Trade Notes, and ETFs, Exchange Traded Funds, are very similar instruments, yet they have a significant difference.
Similarities:
- Both follow an index or a basket of stocks traded in an exchange, so can be traded freely on an intra-day basis (unlike mutual funds which investors can only trade at the end of the day).
- Both have very low fees
Differences:
- ETFs are structured like a mutual fund, you own a piece of the fund, and the corresponding number of shares in the companies or contracts it invests in (in the case of commodities)
- ETNs, on the other hand, are structured as debt, baked by a bank, so there is credit risk. If the bank goes under, so does that ETN. An example are the three ETNs issued by Lehman Brothers in February 2008: Opta S&P Listed Private Equity Index Net Return ETN , Opta Lehman Brothers Commodity Index Pure Beta Total Return ETN and Opta LBCI Pure Beta Agriculture Total Return ETN. You know what happened to Lehman Brothers. As they are treated as debt, in December 2007, the U.S. IRS issued an adverse tax ruling on currency linked ETNs. The rule stated that any financial instrument linked to a single currency regardless of whether the instrument is privately offered, publicly offered or traded on an exchange should be treated like debt for federal tax purposes. This means that any interest is taxable to investors, even though the interest is reinvested and not paid out until the holder sells any such financial instrument, including an ETN, or the contract, matures.
- In theory, ETFs have market risk, while ETNs have market and issuer risk.
Risk.
The Nasdaq states that "Exchange Traded Notes have hidden risks not found in standard Exchange Traded Funds, but they have greater flexibility than ETFs and give investors efficient access to niche markets poorly suited to ETFs. Understanding this risk/reward ratio is the key to ETN investing.ETNs are unsecured debt from their issuer, not direct ownership of stocks, bonds or other assets like ETFs. So if the provider goes bankrupt, investors end up holding the bag. This was the case with Lehman Brothers, whose three ETNs shuttered upon its demise".
Liquidity:
In terms of liquidity, ETFs are 10x larger
- ETNs: $5.6B in assets
- ETFs: $60B in assets
Largest ETFs:
1. SPDRs SPY, 70.73B
2. SPDR Gold Shares GLD, 35.05B
3. iShares MSCI EAFE Index EFA, 34.37B
4. iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index EEM, 33.74B
5. iShares S&P 500 Index IVV, 20.44B
6. PowerShares QQQ QQQQ, 17.09B
7. iShares Barclays TIPS Bond TIP, 16.31B
8. Vanguard Emerging Markets Stock ETF VWO, 14.10B
9. iShares iBoxx $ Invest Grade Corp Bond LQD, 13.33B
10. iShares Russell 2000 Index IWM, 13.14B
11. Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF VTI, 12.35B
12. iShares Barclays Aggregate Bond AGG, 10.62B
13. iShares Russell 1000 Growth Index IWF, 10.42B
14. iShares MSCI Brazil Index EWZ, 10.17B
Largest ETNs:
1. Barclays iPath Dow Jones AIG Commodity Index (DJP)
2. Powershares DB Crude Oil Double Long (DXO)
3. Barclays iPath S&P GSCI Crude Oil (OIL)
Summary
In other words, ETNs act as bonds that don’t pay interest at a fixed rate, but pay a return on a given index. ETNs are typically registered under the Securities Act of 1933.
ETFs are regulated by the Investment Company Act of 1940, ensuring some protection of the assets of the ETF in the case the issuer goes bankrupt. This is not the case with ETNs, which are debt instruments only as good as the credit of the issuer. In other words, if the issuer goes under, your money is lost.
When you buy an ETN, such as OIL from Barclays, you get a promise that it will perform as stated (i.e., the performance of the Goldman Sachs Crude Oil Return Index). When you buy the USO ETF, you actually own some futures contracts on barrels of oil. If the fund manager goes under, shares should contunue to trade or your money will be exchanged for the shares, at least in theory.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
ETNs vs ETFs
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(843)
-
▼
October
(170)
- Correlation Of All Commodity ETFs
- Correlations Among All Currency ETFs and Gold
- Stock Correlations For September and October 2009:...
- Profit From Oil or Gold Going Up or Down
- BNN Exclusive Interview With Paul Volcker, On the ...
- Japan, The Land of The Setting Sun, Will the U.S. ...
- BMO Launches 9 New ETFs: Novelties And Cannibalism...
- SPY, IWM, XLF, AUY, UCO, EWZ Straddles Update
- Silver Wheaton: SLW vs SLW.TO, Can You Profit From...
- U.S. Jobless Claims Are Above 500,000 For 42 Conse...
- Natural Gas Inventories at New Record High, Analysis
- FSLR Dissappoints, Straddles Go Up
- S&P 500 Index (SPX): The Rally Illusion
- Martin Feldstein: It's Not "Too Big To Fail", It's...
- SPY, IWM, AUY, KGC Straddles Results PM
- Android Kills Garmin, But Garmin May Resurrect
- Has Gold Topped?
- SPY, IWM, XLF, EWZ, AUY, KGC Straddles Results
- Financials Are Scary, But HIG, Hartford Financial ...
- Unemployment Worsens in 371 of 372 U.S. Metropolit...
- USO Backtesting of Daily, Weekly, and Monthly Alerts
- Profit From Oil Going Up Or Down
- Live Tracking of All 115 Leveraged ETFs On the Market
- The Lithium Bubble: One Company's Lithium Reserves...
- ETNs vs ETFs
- Icici Bank (IBN) Down Sharply Today
- First Solar and Vale Report Earnings: Options
- Roubini and the Carry-Trade Bubbles, Where Has He ...
- China Again Says Reverve Currency Should Move Away...
- Forget Gold and Oil: Soft Commodities Are Skyrocke...
- Live Tracking of Top Technology Companies In The M...
- Foreign Currencies Take a Beating
- Aetna Play for Earnings
- Amazon (AMZN) to The Moon... and Back
- New Bombs to Hit The Markets: Commercial Mortgage ...
- Commodities Heading Higher Are Key to Inflation or...
- Food Prices Rise 80% in Developing Countries
- Live Tracking Top Financial Companies
- Option Plays For The Top Stock Movers in The S&P500
- S&P500 Report For Week of October 26: 39 Oversold,...
- The Most Under and Over Valued Commodity ETFs In T...
- Top 20 ETFs to Buy And To Sell Out of 770 ETFs Fo...
- Analysis of SPY and IWM Straddles Chances
- Alternative to Trading Physical Gold Video: GLD to...
- Roubini: Oil To Drop $50, Gold Has Nowhere To Go,...
- Future Mortgage Resets Chart: A Lot of Pain Coming Up
- Housing Sales "Up" In The U.S, But The Devil is in...
- Global Loans, Credits, and Cash Flows Continue to ...
- Top Cellular and Internet Usage Countries in the W...
- Natural Gas Inventories: Storage At Record
- H1N1 Vaccine: Novartis Will Not Deliver In Time
- Huge Volume of November IWM Puts Traded
- World's Largest Pure Gold Coin, Worth $400M
- Options To Protect and Profit From the Market Crash
- Investors Already Find Ways to Invest in Brazil an...
- Live Tracking of all Gold, Silver, Precious Metals...
- Video: U.S. Banks Are Engaged in Fraud
- The Nasdaq is in Thin Air Zone
- Volkwagen: Brazil To Move Up as 2nd Largest Market...
- Stock Market Hits The Point of Diminishing Returns
- Oil Going Parabolic: Straddles Results
- New Site For Live Tracking of All Commodity ETFs. ...
- Apple (AAPL) Earnings Straddles Update: +25% ROI
- King Calls for U.K. Banks to be Broken Apart: Bigg...
- Trading Results Based on Monthly Trade Triangle Al...
- Chicago Exchange to Accept Gold as Collateral for ...
- AAPL and EWZ Straddles Results
- Earnings Straddles for APPL, TXN and ZION
- Brazilian Real Cut To Underweight
- New Site for Live Tracking of All Oil ETFs (Single...
- SPY, IWM, XLF, Miners and Oil Straddles for Market...
- The Top 20 ETFs to Buy and To Sell Out of 776 ETFs
- S&P500 RSI-A Report: 125 Companies to Sell, Only 6...
- How Goldman Sachs Made Their Profits in Q3 Using Y...
- Backtesting of INO's Trade Triangle Tool
- What Oil Will Do in Winter
- UNG Straddles With Expiry Today
- PBR, PetroBras, Now World's Fifth Largest Company
- Natural Gas Report: Storage Overflow in 2.4 Weeks
- A Technique for Making Money Using SPY, GLD, USO, ...
- Dollar Rises Versus Kenyan Currency (Wow)
- UCO, Oil Straddles For November
- Red Alert Triggered For Gold
- Top Performer in 2009: A Builder, +291% YTD
- Van Eeden: Gold to Drop, U.S. Dollar to Rise, Chin...
- Nokia Loses $831M, Stock Down 11%, USD Big Factor
- UNG Straddles Results From Last Week
- The U.S. Dollar: Take One, It's Free.
- A Little Precious Stone Worth $125M, or $92M per O...
- The Great FED Divide Will Kill The U.S. Dollar
- 40% of European Companies Abandon NYSE
- Recent Green and Red Stock Alerts Generated
- 5 Ways to Protect Yourself or Profit From the U.S....
- Natural Gas Play for Tomorrow
- Top 10 Global ETFs To Buy and To Sell Out of All G...
- U.S. Dollar to Fall Further Versus Real
- Kohn, The Fed's No. 2 Man, Says No V-Shaped Recovery
- Live Tracking of All Global ETFs
- New U.S. Dollar Alert Triggered
- Live Tracking of Health Companies Affected by U.S....
-
▼
October
(170)
No comments:
Post a Comment