Olympics is huge business and Vancouver 2010 will be no different. The Vancouver Sun estimates costs at around $6B, including many of the hidden costs. The Olympic torch is touring across Canada and was in Ottawa this weekend.
I had the pleasure and privilege of seeing it, literally a couple of feet away, as well as the actual Olympic flame (which is not the same as the torch!):
You can view the exact torch location live as it is carried across Canada on this map.
Costs & Benefits
As for costs and benefits, they are all over the place. The benefits are many an varied and very hard to measure. The Center for Policy Alternatives says:
“If Vancouver hosts the 2010 Winter Olympics, there will be a substantial net cost to British Columbians in the order of $1.2 billion, even taking into account increased tax revenues and the benefit of not having to upgrade the Sea-to-Sky highway at a later date.” And as the sole guarantor of the Games, the Province of British Columbia is assuming all the financial burden of what is clearly a risky business venture.”
"“That’s not to say the Olympics don’t have benefits,” says Mauboules. “The positive impacts for British Columbians include the pride and enjoyment from hosting the Games, the opportunity to attend events, and the use of new sports, housing and transportation facilities, to name a few.” Seth Klein, the CCPA’s BC Director, says the question for policy makers and the public is: Do the benefits outweigh the substantial price tag that comes with hosting the Games? “To date, the public has received inadequate information about the costs and benefits of hosting the Winter Olympics. We’ve basically done government’s job for them. Both federal and provincial guidelines recommend the use of multiple account evaluations for such an initiative. Yet neither level of government, nor the Bid Corporation, has undertaken such an evaluation.” “The Olympics have too often been pitched as having miraculous economic powers,” says Klein “They do not. Like all public policy choices, they come with benefits and costs, and will require trade-offs.”"
Here is another study, which says "We have come to the conclusion that most of the research which shows the Games earning profits and boosting the economy comes from government sources whereas the negative effects are uncovered by private sources"
"Benefits and advantages realized are that you can attend the games relatively easy; locals won’t have to travel far. Facilities will be useful as legacies will remain in use after the games. Jobs help growth which results in migration and local spending. Tourism will be at all time high due to media coverage. B.C then becomes more appealing, and tourists become aware of what the province has to offer. On top of that there is the considered prestige on an international stage if everything runs smoothly and goes according to plan. "
"The Vancouver Organizing Committee has estimated that only 30% of ticket sales will be purchased by foreigners. This obviously means that 70% of the tickets will be purchased by BC residents, and the majority of those will be residents of the GVRD. The problem with this is discussed in the paper “The effect of professional sports on earnings and employment in the services and retail sectors in US cities.” Coates and Humphreys (2002). It explains that professional sports have a negative effect on the economy as a whole. The reason behind this is that the sports franchise acts as a substitute with other entertainment and services around the city. So instead of a typical consumer spending money on a new t-shirt and going to the movies, they will buy a shirt at the stadium and watch the game. This doesn’t create any economic stimulation; it only substitutes the money from one area to another. The Games will feel a similar effect with ticket sales. Although the government is expecting the tourists to spend money in Vancouver and Whistler, the local residents will likely shift their spending from other entertainment to the Games, thus creating a substitution of goods and offsetting the increase of tourist spending with the decrease in local consumption. Of course the tourist spending will help the local stores but the government has treated the local consumer spending as if there is no trade off. "
Sunday, December 13, 2009
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Torch
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(843)
-
▼
December
(94)
- China To Maintain Economic Policies in 2010
- Stiglitz: Make Greater Progress On Financial Refor...
- Idle and Full Oil Tankers Would Stretch for 43Km
- Cold Weather: UNG/Natural Gas Plays For Tomorrow
- Stock Markets Could Be Flat For Years
- Sovereign Debt Update: Europe At Great Risk
- Tiger Woods Scandal Costs Shareholders $5B to $12B
- Sprott Says S&P Will Drop Below March 09 Lows, So ...
- Special Stock Tool Access For Shocked Investor Rea...
- Concerns Escalate On Sovereign Debt Defaults: Who ...
- Gold Down and US Dollar Up in December: Temporary ...
- The Chaos With Global Currencies and The Creation ...
- Freddie and Fannie Get Unlimited License to Print ...
- 2010 Stock Market And World Economy Outlook: An En...
- The New U.S. Dollar Will Surprise You and Scare You
- Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays
- Goldman Sachs Builds New Headquarters in New York:...
- $9M For Schumacher, Hundreds of Millions For F-1
- Diversifying From the US Dollar: Best Commodities ...
- GDP Revised Down Again: Why Believe In The Lies?
- Chile: Stellar Financial Performance That Teaches ...
- Roubini Says US Dollar Has 6 More Months of Lows, ...
- Top Global Currency ETFs To Move Away From The US ...
- Coxe: Copenhagen and The Jihad Against Global Warm...
- Brazilian Oil Production To Top Mexico's and Venez...
- The Top Countries At Risk of Default
- Canadian ABCP Saga: Just a $130M Settlement
- Brazilian Metro Unemployment Is Lowest On Record i...
- Citibank Astounding Options Activity, and "An Oppo...
- S&P500: SPY December Max Pain is 105
- Dollar Up, Gold Down: Straddles Results
- Has The US Dollar Botommed Out? Conflicting Long a...
- Citibank Shares Plummet on News of New Shares To B...
- Citibank: Massive Number of Puts Traded Ahead of A...
- Bovespa 2010 Projections: Targets Range From 80,00...
- Straddles For Fed Notes Release Tomorrow: Throwing...
- 2010 Global GDP Growth: China Leads, Indonesia 2nd...
- All Major Banks Have Repaid TARP: It's a Myth, Inv...
- The 787 Dreamliner is Flying (Pictures)
- Boeing Dreamliner 1st Flight Attempt Today: Succes...
- Manufacturers Index Crashes to 2.55
- Why Indonesia and Vietnam Should be Added to the BRIC
- Roubini Global Economics: Remove Russia From BRIC
- Bank Failures Reach New Records in 2009
- Tamiflu Resistance and The Fall of H1N1 Drug Compa...
- Top 20 ETFs to Buy and To Sell Out of 776 ETFs
- Vancouver 2010 Olympic Torch
- The Plundering of The U.S.: Public Servants Making...
- China's Big Oil Mistery: Car Sales "Up" Yet Low Oi...
- Insurers Get Capital Boost Out of Thin Air, Throug...
- Are the Markets Ready To Collapse? What to Watch F...
- Canadians Pay Twice as Much As Americans for Natur...
- Jim Rogers: The Fed Should Be Audited and... Aboli...
- Stiglitz: Overwhelming Force Needed, Government Sh...
- People on Emergency Unemployment: 4.1M in Nov 2009...
- 21M Homes Behind Payments, Defaults by Convenience...
- Best Dividend ETFs To Buy and to Short
- Volkswagen Buys 20% of Suzuki, Targets Toyota For ...
- Bear Market Rallies Are To Be Rented, Not Owned
- Profit From Japan Stocks Or The Yen Going Up or Down
- A Big Japan Oops: Growth of 1.8% Instead Of The Es...
- Rice Prices Increasing Significantly, ETNs and Fut...
- Bernanke Chosen As Top Global Thinker; Roubini, Nu...
- Meredith Whitney: The U.S. Has Run Out of Bullets:...
- Straddles For The Recovery Of The U.S. Dollar and ...
- Consumer Credit Drops For 9th Straight Month: A Ne...
- Buy and Sell Long Term Alerts Generated Today, Inc...
- Carbon Derivatives, The Next CDS Scheme?
- Best Currency ETFs To Buy and To Short
- Natural Gas Storage in Overflow: Last Year's Decli...
- SEC Says To Investigate High-Frequency Trading, Go...
- A Great ETF To Play Carbon Dioxide Being Declared ...
- Gold Deals: Franco Nevada Buying ROY, Stock Up 50%.
- Barrick Gold Downgraded, Possible Bankruptcy
- Why The Unemployment Rate Dropped: 291,000 People ...
- Profit From Where Oil and USO are Headed
- Proper Investment Diversification With All Commodi...
- Highest Return on Assets Among All Banks in The Am...
- What About Global Bubbles? Bernanke Says The US Se...
- How to Profit From the US Dollar Collapsing Furthe...
- How To Profit From the Rise Or Crash of Gold, Oil,...
- Strong Long-Term Buy and Sell Alerts Issued In The...
- Lumber Stocks Set For Explosive Move Up As China M...
- Dubai Fallout: Key Your Mercedes Benz
- Investor Sentiment Is The Lowest Bearish in 25 Years
- Beige Book Analysis: Conditions Very Weak, Commerc...
- Analysis of All Global ETFs: How To Properly Diver...
- Let The States Lend Directly To The People For 2% ...
- Straddles Update, Post Dubai
- The Hope for Japan: Social Upheaval. Yen to Fall Hard
- Correlations Among Stocks, Oil, Gold, Currencies i...
- Correlations For DIA and SPY Have Gone Haywire in ...
- 10,000,000,000,000 Yens To Fight Deflation and Dri...
- Companies Drastically Cut Lawyer Costs: Virtual La...
-
▼
December
(94)
1 comment:
Interesting article.
"it only substitutes the money from one area to another. " is too simplistic. This assumes that everyone is interested in all activities equally. How many people pass on the opera to see a hockey game or vice versa?
We have wanted to visit Vancouver for many years but have put it off but we are coming for the Olympics. Even though, as visitors from the US, we probably won't get tickets to any event. That is a net gain for Vancouver.
Our local Winter Olympics site, Squaw Valley, CA. is still playing off the event 50 years later and has benefited, at some monetary level, every year from it.
Post a Comment