With the high volatility of the U.S. Dollar lately, and its recent near-collapse, investors are right in looking for ways to preserve their money and look at currency ETFs.
This article looks at the UUP and UDN funds. They are bull and bear versions of the U.S. Dollar index offered by Powershares. It invests in futures contracts "with a view to tracking the changes, whether positive or negative, in the level of the Deutsche Bank US Dollar Index (USDX) Futures Index."
I have done a thorough analysis of these ETfs for 2008 and 2009 and have compared their performance with the expected performance. I wrote a piece of software to do the analysis of over 1M data points. The results are shown in this article.
WHAT SHOULD HAPPEN
In a trending environment, it should be a good plan to buy both versions of bull and bear ETFs. This is due to compounding effect day after day. For example, in a theoretical scenario where a stock moves up 1% per day, for 100 consecutive days, and you hold both bull and bear 1X versions of the corresponding ETFs, your total performance would be +52.3%. The bull version goes up +167%, the bear version goes down for a return of -63%. Because the losses in terms of dollars are smaller and smaller every day, and the dollar gains of the bull version afer greater day after day, the overall strategy is a winner. Please see the chart below, which shows what happens with $10 invested in each ETF, for a total $20 initial investment.
It is a clear winner in a trending environment. Note that this has nothing to do with leveraged ETFs, these are just plain simple 1X ETFs.
Now, in an alternating highly volatile market, the opposite should occur, however, the total losses are much smaller. The following chart shows the same investment after 100 days, assuming the market goes up 1% one day, then down 1% the next day, up 1% the next, and so on.
The total return now is a loss of -0.49% after 100 days. So, not so bad.
Now what happens with in-between mixed scenarios. The folloing table shows various cases. The more trending the market, the higher the gains. The more volatile the market, the lower the gains. No surprises.
(please click to enlarge)
Here is a summary:
PERFORMANCE OF UUP AND UDN
All nice and dandy. So what happened with UUP and UDN? Let us take a look at 2009, whe the U.S. Dollar was crashing (until yesterday that is).
From Jan. 1 2009 to September 22 2009, UUP went up 8.47%. UDN went down -9.31%. Its was very much a trending environment, with a few ups and down, but mostly trending, as we know. The fact that UDN loses more than UUP gains hapens repetitively, in happened in 145 out of the 182 trading days. That is nearly 80% of the time. This ends up causing significant losses to investors.
I then used my software to run simulations. It analysed what happened with $10k bought in each fund, for every day of 2009. The results are not good:
The table shows the average final dollar ammount (for the total $20k initial investment, $19k in UUP, $10K in UDN) after holding the ETFs for several different lengths of time.
You may view complete results here. It is a large pdf with tens of pages, but shows every single day.
On average, the strategy is a losing one. How was this possible?
In its prospectus, Powershares says the MER is 0.55%, less a gain of 0.16% in interest, for an effective 'fees and expenses" rate of 0.36% for 1 year. If we factor these fees in, we still do not get anywhere near the losses shown in practice. Doing the math, we see that the effective MER for the 182 days is 0.2508%. Each of ETFs will lose this amount over the period (2009 YTD). This is nowhere near the losses we actually see.
So it is another case of buyer beware.
Note: You may receive technical analysis and alerts of UUP ad UDN, sent automatically to you by entering the symbols in the Technical Trend Analysis Tool, (powered by INO).
Thursday, September 24, 2009
U.S. Dollar Investing: Beware the Perils of UUP and UDN
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(843)
-
▼
September
(146)
- Chigago ISM Numbers Were Released Ahead of Time to...
- Top Currency ETFs To Buy and To Sell
- Google Wave: A Terrific New Google Product
- The All Supreme Fed Appeals Order to Release Infom...
- Using Stock Divergences To Predict Stock Movement ...
- Jim Cramer Badly Burned on CIT Call: Stock Crashes...
- Another Reason That The Markets are Going Up: Quar...
- Top Stocks To Buy and Sell in Latin America (ADRs)
- Sugar Hits All-Time High
- A Political-Economic Oligarchy Has Taken Over the ...
- Bill Gross: Deflation; Fisher: The Fed will Agress...
- SQNM, Sequenom Crashes: How to Profit
- Top 10 Occupations Looking for Employees
- Number of Online Help Wanted Ads Declines by 108,0...
- UNG Cannot Find Buyers for New Shares.
- Today's Top 40 Movers: ASTC +185%, LEE +51%, SQNM ...
- FDIC is Asking for a Bailout
- The Future of the Dollar Explained, Why and How it...
- How to Invest in Gold: Physical Gold vs ETFs, Miners
- ETFs to Profit From Options Without Buying or Sell...
- The Top 50 Safest Banks in the World
- Investing in India: At Risk of Oligarchic Capitalism
- Production Lines and Factories Moving to Brazil
- Higher Earnings Due to the Lower U.S.Dollar: Stock...
- Which Central Banks are Worried About Their Curren...
- Insider Buying of Xerox Puts, Large Volumes Bought...
- How to Profit From the Xerox Crash
- Research in Demotion: RIMM Continues to Slide, Str...
- Central Bankers Report Card: Bernanke Ranked a 'C'
- The Current U.S.: a Can Do Nation, or a Can't Do N...
- Bernanke Says "We Did It", Federal Reserve Caused ...
- Protect Your Money: How to Invest in Latin America
- Large Number of SPY Puts: Average ROI of +55
- S&P 500 Report: 13 Overbought and 44 Oversold Comp...
- World Bank: U.S. Should Not Take For Granted Dolla...
- New Bank of the South to be Created To Reduce Depe...
- Google $155B, 11 Years
- Update and Results: Top 50 ETFs To Sell and Buy
- H1N1: Canada Issues Warning Over Tamiflu
- G20 Country Data for GDP Growth, Unemployment, Int...
- G20 Shadows
- What Was Decided by The G20 Meeting
- U.S. Financial System In Even More Precarious Posi...
- Rare Earth Discovery: Quest Uranium Has Major Find
- Investing in Diamonds: Peregrine has Best Find in ...
- IWM Straddles Profit 156%
- Is RIM Taking a Page from Apple? Spectacular Profi...
- Natural Gas Storage: Overflow in 4.9 Weeks
- Agrium, Mosaic, and China: The Potash Wars
- Paul Martin on The Issues Facing the G20 and the F...
- U.S. Dollar Investing: Beware the Perils of UUP an...
- G-20 Meeting: Down Goes Gold, Up Goes the U.S.Dollar
- Part II - How to Profit From The G20 Meeting Volat...
- Be Careful: G20 Meeting to Have Major Effects On C...
- Solar Energy Market to Instantly Boom in Ontario: ...
- The Fed is Creating New Bubbles; Who is Really Bor...
- US Dollar Inflation vs Deflation, Currencies and F...
- Options for ERTS, Electronic Arts Rumoured to Be A...
- RIMM Reports Earnings: Profit Either Way With Stra...
- G-20 Meeting Chaos, and a Very Weakened U.S.
- Straddles to Profit From Surprises From The Fed De...
- Is the Fed Secretly Engaged in Gold Swaps to Keep ...
- Live Tracking Site of H1N1 Companies' Stocks
- Investing in Brazil
- High Potash Prices are Killing Demand
- The Gold Cycles: Next Low Expected Early/Mid Octob...
- G-20 Pre-Agreement Reached Between U.S and Europe,...
- Buyer Beware: Russian Market Set to Surge, or So C...
- Verichip Wins Patent License for Implanted H1N1 De...
- Complete List of Currency ETFs and Their Performan...
- Car Sales After Cash-for-Clunkers: On Target for W...
- H1N1 BioCryst (BCRX) Alert: Stock May Soar or Cras...
- Global Debt: Satyajit Das on Derivatives, The Debt...
- Top 50 ETFs to Buy and Sell Out of the Entire Univ...
- SVA up 543%, Up to 30% of Asia's Population to be ...
- Global Gold Reserves At $1.4T, US Reserves At Only...
- S&P500: 212 Overbought and 8 Oversold, Top 20 Comp...
- China Slows Down: Beijing Office Real Estate Vacan...
- The US Dollar Carry-Trade is Financing Dangerous G...
- Huge Volume of SPY Puts Options Bought for October
- Options Max Pain Theory: Busted
- The Shapes of the Economic Recovery: U, V, W, L, S...
- UNG Rollover Dates, Use of Swaps Will Erode Price ...
- H1N1: Medical Supply Companies Working at Full Bla...
- Max Pain Live Tracking For September 2009: UNG, US...
- Brazilian Capital Inflows Increased by 30.3%, 10th...
- Rob McEwen: Gold to Hit $1,500 in 2010 and $5,000 ...
- UNG, Natural Gas Inventories: Overflow in 6 Weeks
- Trouble in Japan: Aiful, Japan's 3rd Largest Lende...
- US Dollar Hits 11-Month Low Versus Canadian Dollar
- Federal Express Blames Lower Oil Prices for Bad Re...
- Complete List of Top ETFs by Assets, by Issuers, L...
- The Unemployment Spin: Continuing Claims Rise to 6...
- Top 20 Companies Likely to Go Bankrupt
- Paul Krugman: U.S. Unemployment to Peak in 2011
- UNG Wild Straddles
- Cash For Clunkers Ends: Auto Sales Are a Disaster ...
- TIC Outflow Data Is Terrible For The US Dollar
- Currencies: USD continues to Sink, Real +34%, Year...
- Lehman Brothers Collapse 1 Year Later: Where Are T...
-
▼
September
(146)
No comments:
Post a Comment